As someone who enjoys multiple cups of coffee daily—both brewed at home and picked up from cafes—I’ve spent weeks testing some of the best ceramic-coated tumblers on the market. Through my daily coffee rituals, I’ve explored their strengths, weaknesses, and unique features. Ultimately, one tumbler emerged as my personal favorite: the St. Anthony Industries ceramic tumbler. Here’s how it stacks up against two other contenders, the Created Co. Nomad Tumbler and the Fellow Carter Series, and why I think it’s the best choice for most coffee drinkers.
MoonGoat Ceramic Tumbler by St. Anthony Industries ($27)
This tumbler won me over with its sleek design, push-to-fit lid, and clear slide-lock mechanism, which is unique among the three options. While it holds a bit less than 12 ounces when the lid is on (and exactly 12 ounces without the lid), the compact size and lightweight construction make it the easiest to use daily. It’s also the only one with a clear lid, which I find helpful when sipping on the go or gauging how much coffee I have left.
One of the standout features is its NASA-inspired ceramic coating, which allows for a pure taste experience by preventing any metallic flavors. The tumbler boasts double-walled stainless steel construction, providing excellent insulation to keep beverages hot or cold for extended periods. Its sleek design and ergonomic structure make it a stylish and practical choice for on-the-go use.
The price point of $27 is fantastic, offering premium quality at an accessible price. While it doesn’t keep coffee hot for as long as the others, it strikes a great balance: it keeps your coffee warm long enough to enjoy without requiring you to wait hours before sipping.
Key Features I Love:
- Lightest and most compact of the three, fitting standard cup holders perfectly.
- Fully leak-proof lid with a simple slide lock—no screwing required.
- Sleek design and clear lid for a modern, functional aesthetic.
- Ceramic coating ensures coffee tastes great with no metallic aftertaste.
Drawbacks:
- Holds slightly less coffee than the others—just under 12 ounces with the lid.
Created Co. Nomad Tumbler (estimated $35 retail)
This tumbler has a fully ceramic-coated interior and better insulation than the St. Anthony’s, but it fell short due to its lid design flaws. During testing, the lid broke, and replacing it proved difficult. Even before it broke, the lid wasn’t entirely leak-proof—it could handle splashes but not much else.
At an estimated retail price of $35 for a decorated version, the quality didn’t quite justify the price for me. While it holds slightly more coffee than the St. Anthony’s tumbler (closer to 13 ounces), its design feels less refined and more prone to issues over time.
Key Features I Liked:
- Fully ceramic-coated interior for great taste.
- Holds slightly more than 12 ounces of coffee, even with the lid on.
Drawbacks:
- Lid broke during testing, and replacements are hard to find.
- Even when intact, the lid isn’t fully leak-proof.
Fellow Carter Series ($35 for base + $12 slide lid = $47 total)
The Fellow Carter series is undeniably premium. It has the best insulation of the three, keeping coffee piping hot for hours—sometimes too hot. If you like to enjoy your coffee shortly after brewing, you might find this tumbler impractical. I also tested the version with the optional slide lid, which adds another $12 to the already steep $35 base price, bringing the total to $47.
Additionally, the Fellow tumbler doesn’t fit standard cup holders, including those in Toyota vehicles, which is a significant drawback for commuters like me.
Key Features I Liked:
- Exceptional insulation—this thing could keep coffee hot on a desert island.
- Premium materials and great build quality.
Drawbacks:
- Doesn’t fit standard cup holders, making it inconvenient for daily use.
- Keeps coffee too hot for too long, in my opinion.
- Adding the slide lid makes it prohibitively expensive at $47.
Why I Chose St. Anthony Industries
While all three tumblers have their merits, the St. Anthony Industries ceramic tumbler stood out as the best overall. Its compact size, lightweight design, clear lid, and fully leak-proof functionality make it a joy to use every day. At $27, it also offers exceptional value, delivering premium features without the premium price tag.
Yes, it holds a little less coffee than the others, but for me, the ease of use, portability, and taste quality far outweigh that minor drawback. Plus, it fits in every cup holder I’ve tried—a must-have for anyone who spends a lot of time on the road.
If you’re looking for the perfect tumbler to elevate your coffee experience, I wholeheartedly recommend giving the St. Anthony Industries ceramic tumbler a try. You can find it now on https://moongoat.com/products/moongoat-sleek-ceramic-tumbler. It’s a tumbler I use and love every day, and I think you’ll feel the same.